The porsch is firmer but has a totally different feel, sat near the floor, rotates differently, I think they would be evenly matched though. It's more fun at lower speeds and you defo work it less, where you have to really "drive" the porsche to get the most from it, it'll cruise nicely but it's less entertaining below 4k. That said you do work them differently. Horse for courses I guess. The clio has all the mod cons too which is nice. My main gripe is i cant enjoy it with the wife while the kids are young where with the clio i can throw everyone in and go out somewhere. Later life car in my head. Still not properly thought about or tried to sell it. Will drag it off the drive soon for a blast. My other issue is storage, plus if I did sell it on I'd have a chunk to waste on the clio....